When Jimmy Fallon was two seasons into his term at Saturday Night Live, he and castmate Horatio Sanz came up with a holiday spoof late one night. Along with fellow SNL colleagues Chris Katan and Tracy Morgan, Sanz and Fallon performed “I Wish It Was Christmas Today” during a holiday episode in December 2000. The skit was such a hit that the foursome returned to perform it on SNL again before Christmas. “It was just a keyboard and that little guitar, and I didn’t even think it would be anything,” Fallon tells American Songwriter. “We just did it as a goof, and it took off, and then Julian Casablancas redid it and made it into a real song played on the radio.”
Later released by Casablancas as a bonus track on his 2009 album, Phrazes For The Young, the song became a standard on the show and was a springboard for Fallon to venture deeper into the holidays. Still stuck on the holidays, Fallon revised the Christmas cheer with a trifecta of songs within three years, beginning with “It Was a… (Masked Christmas)” in 2021, featuring Ariana Grande and Megan Thee Stallion, followed by “Almost Too Early For Christmas” with Dolly Parton in 2022, and a 2023 entry “Wrap Me Up,” which he co-wrote with Meghan Trainor and went to No. 2 on the Billboard Adult Contemporary Airplay chart.
All three are peppered into Fallons first seasonal album, Holiday Seasoning, featuring his Late Night house band The Roots, former SNL castmate Will Ferrell, Cara Delevingne, Chelsea Handler, “Weird Al” Yankovic, and more.
Holiday Seasoning opens on the closest thing to a traditional on the hyped-up “Christmas Ding-Dong,” before the funkier “Holiday” with the Jonas Brothers, and a ska-tipped “Hey Rudy” with the Roots. Justin Timberlake, who has worked on Fallon’s 2012 Grammy-winning album Blow Your Pants Off and has been the Robin Gibb to his Barry Gibb in their ongoing SNL Bee Gees skit, joins on their laid-back “bromance” ditty, “You’ll Be There.”
Switching genres by track, the festive pastiche folds into the Yankovic-doused polka countdown, “New Year’s Eve Polka 5-4-3-2-1,” a lighter take on the more solemn New Year’s Eve songs in one vignette, and a Roy Orbison-tinged “Chipmunks & Chestnuts” by another. On the folkier “One Glove” Ferrell tells the absurdly comedic tale of a man helping a woman braving the cold—her hands are two different temperatures in the middle of the storm sings Fallon. As the man continues searching for the missing glove, Ferrell adds I could use one of those little hand-warmer things but they never seem to last.
Handler and Fallon twist up harmonies on their psychedelic hymnal, “Merry Happy Christmas,” while the wholesome “Hallmark Movie” takes a dark turn into a Lifetime flick. Off-beat reggaeton moves “Coquito.” A Weezer-y “Weird Cousin” tells the story of an outlier family member, and “Turkey Day” gets a nod on the penultimate, Dylan-esque “Thanksgiving Eve.”
Holiday Seasoning removes the seriousness around the holidays. With all its different seasonings, or genres, Fallon has created the perfect holiday mixtape stuffed with some of the most awkwardly comedic storylines ever written.
“I hope people buy this, and listen to the whole thing like it’s a mixtape since it’s all these different genres,” says Fallon. “In this generation, you listen to playlists, so it should sound like one, like the greatest hits of different artists you can have playing in the background.”
Fallon recently spoke to American Songwriter about the making of his holiday album, finally learning proper songwriting terminology—at 50—and creating the perfect holiday mixtape.
[RELATED: 7 Songs You Didn’t Know Jimmy Fallon Wrote]
American Songwriter: How far back does your obsession fascination with Christmas go? Was “I Wish It Was Christmas Today” (2009) for Saturday Night Live the first holiday song you wrote?
Jimmy Fallon: Yeah, I think that was the first one. I give credit to Horatio Sanz, The holiday show around Saturday Night Live is a big show. Usually, we get good hosts and good musical guests, and everyone’s in good spirits, and the sketches are holiday-themed, and it’s just that music is all over the city with 30 Rock and Christmas Tree lit up. There’s ice skating, the Rockettes, and we’re surrounded by the holidays.
Music fits in perfectly with the holidays, whether you’re having a party or get-together with family or friends, music is always a good ingredient to a good party. So we always try to write some musical something for the holidays, and someone had given me a backpacker guitar for Christmas, which is a tiny little guitar that you can take backpacking. So I had this little guitar, and Horatio was playing with it in the office, and it has this tinky little sound to it, and he got a good riff to it, and we started playing, and it’s probably two in the morning. I have a keyboard from the ‘80s in the office and it had some pre-recorded drum beats and loops that you can play with different chords. So we were pretending we were writing a really, great pop song but with really dumb lyrics, and that’s what we ended up doing.
It was just a keyboard and that little guitar, and I didn’t even think it would be anything. When I came in the next day, he [Sanz] goes “Dude, I submitted that Christmas song.” So then we just did it as a goof. It took off, and then Julian Casablancas redid it and made it into a real song played on the radio.
I’ve always been into it [holiday music]. It’s such a good rush. For this album, Michele Anthony from Universal, who’s just a legend, encouraged me. She was like, “You should do a Christmas album like the 12 Days of Christmas sweaters you do on The Tonight Show, but with 12 covers? I recorded half of one song with a big band type of thing, and it was terrible. It wasn’t my thing. It was corny. I’m not as good as [Michael] Bublé, Kelly Clarkson, or Mariah Carey. They can rock that, and that’s their thing, but it’s just not me. It just feels odd to me to be singing this and not be making a joke about it. I had this song called “Chipmunks and Chestnuts” that’s like a Roy Orbison-type song. When I record them, in my head, I think “Oh, I’m sounding like Roy Orbison.” Then I’ll finish and everyone says “You sounded great. You sounded like Elvis Costello.” That one was a mix of Roy Orbison, Slim Whitman, and Monty Python.
AS: Is “Hey Rudy” you and the Roots’ take on The Specials’ “A Message to You, Rudy” (1979)?
JF: I was going with The Specials. I was also going for The Avalanches’ “Because I’m Me” (2016). I like the da da da da da da—and then you get a rapper in there. With “Hey Rudy,” I also wanted to get a little Barry Gibb Bee Gees in there as well. (Sings a melody Gibb’s signature high-pitched falsetto.) With every single song, I could tell you all the influences and people that inspired it.
AS: Who were you trying to channel on “One Glove” with Will Ferrell?
JF: That’s more of a Warren Zevon type of jam.
AS: And Bob Dylan inspired “Thanksgiving Eve.”
JF: I wanted it to sound like a Dylan bootleg album that would make people say “What is he talking about? He’s going home for Thanksgiving and to the bar.” I was trying to write bad Dylan lyrics to a holiday song. But I think Thanksgiving Eve should be a holiday. I think everyone’s home and they need it. They need an anthem.
AS: Thanksgiving, in general, is often overlooked when it comes to holiday music, so it’s nice that it’s represented on Holiday Seasoning. Then, you also have an ode to New Year’s with “Weird Al” Yankovic.
JF: I was trying to think of the holes we have. I don’t know when the last time someone wrote a comedy holiday album, but either way, we’re due. I was trying to hit every holiday I could think of and with New Year’s Eve, there are no happy songs. They’re all sad. “Auld Lang Syne“” was sad, and Dan Fogelberg (“Same Old Lang Syne,” 1981). And it’s good, but I was like “What genre is so happy that you have no option but to smile?” And it’s polka. To get Weird Al on this … Immediately, he said “I’m in—love it. Do you mind if I rewrite some stuff?” And I’m like “This is so fun. I get to write a song with Weird Al.”
I remember my parents used to have parties when I was growing up, and I used to play music with my two friends. We were called Born Losers, and we would do cover songs at the house. We’d harmonize and sing the Bee Gees, the Troggs, the Animals, the Beatles, and Nirvana. And after we’d stop—hopefully, we didn’t clear the party out—I would DJ and play music. So I made sure when I did this vinyl, that side-two track one is “New Year’s Eve Polka,” just in case I’ve had a couple of cocktails. You don’t have to look with a flashlight like “What track is this?” It’s the first song, side two. I got you covered.
AS: Dolly Parton didn’t co-write “Almost Too Early for Christmas,” but did most of these collaborators have a hand in writing?
JF: Yeah, we all got in there. With the Jonas Brothers, I was in the studio in LA where a lot of the Jackson 5 albums were recorded. So I wanted to do Jackson’s “Blame It on the Boogie” type of jam. Everything starts with a voice memo on my phone. Originally “Holiday” with the Jonas Brothers was called “Silent Night.” Then it turned into holiday, time to celebrate and we got in some Nile Rodgers. I wanted to have that Le Chic groove to it like a roller disco type of song. We just shot a video for that one and the Jones Brothers are trapped in a snow globe singing.
AS: You also got to work with Justin Timberlake again.
JF: Sometimes you’re at the studio and Ryan Tedder is next door and Greg Aldae [Hein] who had just written “Flowers” with Miley [Cyrus]. So they go “You want to write a song?” We wrote a bromance song for Timberlake. It’s me calling Justin Timberlake, saying, “Hey, can we hang out this holiday?” And he doesn’t call me back. So we found one night and went to Electric Lady [Electric Lady Studios in New York City], and stayed till two, three in the morning, laughing and rewriting.
That guy [Timberlake] is a professional. He is a perfectionist. He’s a talented, talented human being. Do you ever think that your friends don’t really work? You go to your friend’s job and go “Whoa, you work?” That’s Justin Timberlake. This is the most talented guy. He harmonized with himself. He produced the track. He added instruments. He played the keyboard on it. He’ll say “Put this on the left side, put this on the right side.” It’s so fun to watch and I learned a lot. I’ve always had respect for writers and recording artists, but man, it’s a lot of work to put out an album of originals.
AS: But you’ve been writing for a while since your debut The Bathroom Wall (2002). Are you a better songwriter now?
JF: Completely. Without a doubt. I actually know what a bridge is, which I didn’t know before. I didn’t know what was going on. I’m learning all this stuff, this terminology. I remember writing with Meghan Trainor, and I needed a rhyme for the line I’ll go get the ribbons, which rhymes with nothing and she goes Honey, you don’t get it. She said if you say “ribbons” right it will rhyme with “get it.” It makes no sense, but then you listen to the song. … She’s a genius. With Meghan, we charted. It was the best thing that ever happened to me. It’s like That Thing You Do moment when they’re playing your song on the radio.
When I do songs by myself, I have a little bit more confidence, because I can be weirder. I just throw it down there and get as weird as I can because I grew up with novelty records and Dr. Demento and Weird Al.
I also don’t want to let an artist down if they’re doing a song with me. I want to be professional and make sure all the things are there and it’s well written. When I worked with Dolly Parton, I didn’t want to waste one second of her time. And she’s the best to work with. I said, “Let’s start here, and if we end up doing another song, we can get a little weirder.” Now, she trusts me and she turned the song into a whole new thing. She made it professional, and it sounds great.
I have artists come on the show, and that’s their whole life. They wake up and they write songs. Taylor Swift writes a song every day. That’s their workout. I tell jokes, but they write songs and it’s such an art.
AS: And now you’ve learned more about that side of your songwriting.
JF: Yeah, at 50 years old, you can still learn (laughs). I’m learning and I’ve gotten a gazillion times better, from the scratch on my phone to what the song turned out to be, the whole layers, and the breaking down of a song. I hope people buy this, and listen to the whole thing like it’s a mixtape since it’s all these different genres.
In this generation, you listen to playlists, so it should sound like one, like the greatest hits of different artists you can have playing in the background. Then you can walk away, and go “That was good, and that was weird—and it’s fun.” Hopefully, it can be part of your tradition every year. It’s crazy for me, because I grew up listening to everyone else, and the fact that I’m lucky enough to do this … I’m the luckiest guy on the earth.
‘Holiday Seasoning’ Tracklist:
1. ”Christmas Ding Dong”
2. “Holiday” with the Jonas Brothers
3. “Hey Rudy” with The Roots
4. “Wrap Me Up (Meghan Trainor)
5. “You’ll Be There” with Justin Timberlake
6. “It Was A… (Masked Christmas)” with Ariana Grande and Megan Thee Stallion
7. “How You Know It’s Christmastime” “
8. “New Year’s Eve Polka (5-4-3-2-1)” with “Weird Al” Yankovic & the Roots)
9. “Chipmunks & Chestnuts”
10. “One Glove” with Will Ferrell
11. “Merry Happy Christmas” with Chelsea Handler
12. “Coquito”
13. “Hallmark Movie” with Cara Delevingne
14. “Weird Cousin”
15. “Thanksgiving Eve”
16. “Almost too early for Christmas” with Dolly Parton
Photos: Vijat Mohindra / Courtesy of Republic Records
